| | Perry Andre | JR | | | | Wauseon, Ohio | Hesston College |
| | Mark Baker | JR | M | | | Leicester, England | Lincoln Land Community College |
| | Aaron Bontrager | FR | | | | Archbold, Ohio | Archbold HS |
| | Jackson Bush | FR | | | | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton HS |
| 0 | Rafael Correa | SO | GK/M | | | Ligonier, Ind. | West Noble HS |
| | Andrew Eisenbeis | FR | | | | Marion, S.D. | Freeman Academy |
| | Moti Endalew | JR | M | | | Minneapolis, Min. | St. Paul College |
| | Isaiah Garza | FR | | | | Warsaw, Ind. | Warsaw Community HS |
| | Andrew Glick | SO | M | | | Pekin, Ill. | Pekin Community HS |
| | Brock GunderKline | JR | | | | Yellow Springs, Ohio | Homeschooled |
| | Seth Miller | FR | | | | Wellman, Iowa | Iowa Mennonite HS |
| | Micah Miller Eschlman | SO | M | | | Dover, Ohio | Dover HS |
| | Wagner Moreira | JR | M | | | Sao Paulo, Brazil | Waldorf College |
| | Juan Moya | FR | | | | Quito, Ecuador | Alliance Academy |
| | Jacob Nofziger | SO | D | | | Archbold, Ohio | Pettisville HS |
| | Brian O'Leary | JR | | | | Seattle, Wash. | Ballard HS |
| | Madi Ouedraogo | SO | | | | Burkino Faso | |
| | Lucas Perez | SO | | | | Vinhedo, Brazil | Waldorf College |
| | Benjamin Pollitt | FR | | | | Helsby, England | Helsby HS |
| | Josh Snyder | JR | M | | | Kalona, Iowa | Hesston College |
| | Josh Stiffney | JR | F | | | Goshen, Ind. | Goshen HS |
| | Ben Troyer | FR | | | | Wooster, Ohio | Central Christian HS |
| | Joel Yoder | FR | | | | Goshen, Ind. | Bethany Christian HS |
| | Jared Zook | FR | | | | Canton, Ohio | Central Christian HS |
| 1 | Ryan Troyer | SR | GK | | | Fredericksburg, Ohio | Waynesdale HS |
| 2 | Raymond Waweru | SR | M | | | Nairobi, Kenya | Light Academy |
| 3 | Joseph Gunden | SO | M | | | Chelsea, Mich. | Chelsea HS |
| 4 | Martin Brubaker | SR | D | | | Goshen, Ind. | Bethany Christian HS |
| 5 | Lewis Caskey | JR | D | | | Goshen, Ind. | Bethany Christian HS |
| 6 | Jesse Ramer | SO | D | | | Goshen, Ind. | Western Michigan University |
| 7 | Connor Histand | SR | D | | | Quakertown, Pa. | Christopher Dock HS |
| 8 | Alejandro Davalos | JR | M | | | Lima, Peru | Markham College |
| 9 | Mahomed Yarba Meissara | SO | F | | | Atar, Mauritania | Teyarett HS |
| 10 | Greg Thiessen | SR | F | | | Austin, Texas | Westwood Christian HS |
| 11 | Alain Chaponniere | SR | F | | | Holland, Mich. | West Ottowan HS |
| 12 | Jake Driver | SO | D | | | Goshen, Ind. | Goshen HS |
| 13 | Joel Maust | SR | F | | | Goshen, Ind. | Goshen HS |
| 14 | Caleb Frey | SO | M | | | Shipshewana, Ind. | Westview HS |
| 15 | Jan Dohnal | JR | F | | | Hluk, Czech Republic | Palacky University |
| 16 | Josh Van Allen | SO | M | | | Leicester, England | Lincoln Land Community College |
| 17 | Caleb Longenecker | FR | M | | | Grayslake, Ill. | Grayslake Central HS |
| 18 | Julian Sider | SR | D | | | Harrisonburg, Va. | Eastern Mennonite HS |
| 19 | Dennis Chavez | JR | M | | | Barnesville, Ohio | Olney Friends HS |
| 20 | Aaron Shelly | JR | M | | | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton HS |
| 21 | Daniel Martin | JR | F | | | Salem, Ore. | Western Mennonite HS |
| 22 | Jacob Yoder | SO | F | | | Wellman, Iowa | Iowa Mennonite HS |
| 23 | Jordan Berkey | SO | M | | | Topeka, Ind. | Westview HS |
| 24 | Aaron Stiffney | FR | D | | | Goshen, Ind. | Bethany Christian HS |
| 25 | Carlos Soto | JR | M | | | Irapuato, Mexico | Waldorf College |